For many years, perhaps even decades, conducting a background check on job candidates has been the standard. But, in recent years, there's been a lot of discussion surrounding whether background checks are necessary, or even ethical.
Are background checks discriminatory?
Many people argue that performing checks on a potential employee's history, such as criminal record checks and credit checks, unfairly discriminates against people who have either committed minor offenses or been victims of poverty. For example, if an applicant has a DUI (driving under the influence) charge or conviction against their name, it usually automatically bars them from being accepted for a role, even if they're not required to drive for the role itself, or the offense was committed long ago.
In terms of credit checks, some applicants may fail the screening process because simply put, their incomes are low or their credit scores are bad due to no fault of their own. In response, more than 10 states now ban employers from conducting credit checks before hiring. And as of 2026, 37 states and 150 municipalities have adopted “ban the box” have adopted laws or policies for public sector laws. These initiatives require the removal of questions about conviction or arrest histories from job applications and delay criminal background checks until later in the hiring process.
In addition, some employers are trying to be more transparent in their hiring processes, according to Cornell University’s School of Industrial and Labor Relations. These employers are updating their hiring procedures to avoid liability stemming from discrimination claims and to address labor market challenges. By revisiting background check requirements, employers may be able to bring more candidates into their labor pool in a job market that remains challenging for key industries such as manufacturing.
Now let’s take a closer look at some of the downsides and upsides of background checks.
The cons of background checks
- They’re time-consuming: Contacting banks for credit scores or going digging through legal archives to locate criminal records potentially wastes valuable time that could be spent elsewhere in the organization more constructively.
- They can eliminate qualified candidates: When employers choose to automatically disqualify would-be employees based on their conviction or credit history, they might lose out on hiring highly qualified, well-suited people.
- They may harm an organization's reputation: When companies decide not to hire someone based solely on their criminal, credit or medical records, it's often tantamount to discrimination based on race, class or disability. Understandably, when the general public hears this is happening, the organization in question often earns a poor reception.
The pros of relaxing screening activities
- It can speed up the recruitment process: By choosing to lower the disqualifying criteria or choosing not to conduct background checks altogether, human resources and recruitment teams free up time they could use to increase productivity elsewhere in the business.
- It can widen the talent pool: When employers choose not to disqualify candidates based on arrest or conviction records, or they're more selective with which offenses and sentences disqualify candidates, they have more candidates to choose from.
- It can improve an organization's image: Today, people can find almost any information about any company. In a world that's becoming more progressive and aware of systemic discrimination, by adhering to fair and equal opportunity hiring practices, organizations can improve how they are perceived by the public.
Employbridge’s approach to background checks
Employbridge conducts background checks on applicants after making a conditional offer of employment. Employbridge will conduct all third-party background checks in accordance with the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), other applicable federal and state laws, and Employbridge procedures.
What’s included in a background check will depend on job and client requirements, and we complete E-Verify for all associates before onboarding. To learn more about our approach to background checks and client support, contact us today.